On Monday, while the president was on his way to Asia, his White House counsel sent a one-page memo to the top lawyer at every federal agency. It says that before any employee agrees to appear before a congressional committee, the agency has to notify two White House offices and get their approval: the counsel’s office and Legislative Affairs. Will Scharf, who wrote it, calls this “the established White House consultation process.”
The memo doesn’t say what the criteria for approval are. It sets no deadline for an answer. It doesn’t say what happens when the request arrives as a subpoena. A White House official told Axios the administration “will not be extorted, intimidated, or threatened into submission,” and then added, “We are ready to engage with Congress.”
In forty-seven days, both chambers of that Congress change hands.
Three moves since the election
Read alone, the memo is a process note. Read against the last two weeks, it’s the third move in a sequence.
First, Todd Blanche went on CNN and left open a Justice Department response to congressional oversight. “It depends on what’s said. So yes, there could be,” he said, and softened it a few days later.
Second, on November 9, Scharf wrote to Robert Garcia, the California Democrat expected to chair House Oversight, warning that some of the investigations Democrats have promised could exceed Congress’s authority and might amount to criminal conduct. “Congressional investigations must further a legitimate legislative task,” he wrote. Garcia answered that the power to investigate comes from Article I and doesn’t depend on the White House’s opinion of it.
Third, the memo. The letter told the committees what they may ask. The memo decides who is allowed to answer.
The law from 1912
This has been tried before, and the answer to it is still on the books.
In the first decade of the last century, Theodore Roosevelt and then William Howard Taft issued executive orders restricting federal employees from communicating with Congress except through their department heads. Postal workers and clerks who wanted to tell a committee about their own working conditions could be fired for doing it. Congress responded in 1912, in a postal appropriations bill, with a provision that took the names of its sponsors: the Lloyd-La Follette Act.
Its descendant is Section 7211 of Title 5, and it is one sentence long. The right of federal employees, alone or together, to petition Congress, or to furnish information to either house, to a committee or to a member, “may not be interfered with or denied.”
There is no clause about consultation. There is no exception for an established process.
The paycheck rule
Congress has known for a long time that a right with no penalty is a suggestion, so it added one. Since the late 1990s, the government-wide spending bills have carried a rider that cuts off the salary of any federal official who “prohibits or prevents, or attempts or threatens to prohibit or prevent” another employee from communicating with Congress.
The modern version was written in 1998, Roll Call reported, at the request of House Republicans who were frustrated with the Clinton administration and wanted a direct line from agency staff to appropriators. It has been renewed since under presidents of both parties. House Democrats threatened to invoke it in 2019, during the first impeachment inquiry, when the State Department was telling its diplomats to stay home.
The mechanism is slow and specific. A lawmaker asks the Government Accountability Office to investigate. GAO issues a legal opinion. If it finds a violation, the agency is told to claw back the pay.
Enforced twice
Roll Call found two cases.
The first was in 2004. Richard Foster, Medicare’s chief actuary, had cost estimates for the new prescription drug benefit that lawmakers wanted to see before they voted. Thomas Scully, who ran the agency, threatened to fire him if he handed them over. The bill passed narrowly. GAO concluded that Scully’s order “made HHS’ appropriation, otherwise available for payment of his salary, unavailable for such purpose.” The administration, backed by the Justice Department, said the rider was unconstitutional because it “could force the disclosure of privileged, classified, or deliberative information.” Scully later wrote that he never inhibited anyone.
The second involved the Department of Housing and Urban Development. GAO found that two officials had barred a regional director, Maurice McGough, from cooperating with a congressional inquiry for twelve business days in April 2013. Republicans in Congress pursued it for four years. In June 2017, HUD told one of the two officials he owed $7,176.
That’s the record. A sentence from 1912, a penalty from 1998, two findings, and one bill for seven thousand dollars that arrived four years late.
The White House’s best argument
It deserves a fair statement, because some of it is true.
Every administration coordinates testimony. No cabinet secretary walks into a hearing without clearing it, and no White House would let one. The memo’s verb is “agrees to appear,” which is about scheduling formal testimony, and nothing in the reported text forbids an employee from picking up a phone. A 2004 Justice Department opinion, written during the Foster fight, held that senior officials can restrict what employees give Congress in some circumstances, on the president’s authority over his own branch. Scharf will say he wrote down what was always done.
The trouble is two words: “any employee.” The practice that was always done covered principals and political appointees. This memo reaches the career auditor, the actuary and the regional director, which is to say it reaches Richard Foster and Maurice McGough, the two people the paycheck rule has ever been used to protect. And an approval with no criteria and no deadline works as a pocket veto. Nobody has to say no. The request just has to sit.
Who it reaches first
The investigations Democrats have already announced run through career staff. The FAA technicians whose union says they were left out of the upgrade that grounded every plane in the country on Friday. The Commerce Department employees who processed export licenses for Nvidia’s chips. The Pentagon staff who know what sits behind the Hegseth impeachment referral. None of them is a cabinet secretary, and until Monday none of them needed the White House counsel’s permission to say yes to a committee.
Why it works anyway
Picture the person this is aimed at. She’s a GS-13 at an agency that will be under investigation by February. A committee staffer calls. Under the memo, her agency’s general counsel now has to ask the White House before she agrees to anything.
She may know the 1912 law protects her. She also knows what the remedy looks like: a GAO opinion, six months to four years from now, addressed to somebody else’s paycheck. The criminal statute on obstructing a congressional inquiry is enforced by the Justice Department, and she has heard what its leadership thinks of congressional inquiries. Her mortgage is due on the first.
Most people in that chair don’t return the call. A memo like this does its work by existing. It never has to be tested in court to succeed, and it’s cheap to withdraw if it ever is.
Delay is the other half. In April 2019 the president said, “We’re fighting all the subpoenas,” and he meant it. The House subpoenaed his former White House counsel, Don McGahn, that month. McGahn testified in June 2021, after the president who had blocked him was out of office. A Congress has two years. A well-run stall takes longer than that.
What the next Congress holds
This part is my read of the tools, and I’m not a lawyer.
The rider is annual, and starting in January the spending bills are written by the new majority. It can be sharpened: a deadline for any consultation, an automatic clawback, a line naming this memo. That’s the 1912 answer again, delivered the same way, in an appropriations bill.
A subpoena to an individual is compulsory, and the memo is silent on subpoenas. Inspectors general and the whistleblower channels don’t run through an agency’s general counsel. Every nominee the Senate confirms from here on can be asked, under oath, whether they’ll honor Section 7211. And GAO can be asked on the first day for an opinion on the memo itself, so that the six-month clock starts in January and runs out before the first witness is blocked.
None of those is fast, and Scharf knows that. The memo is one page, and the law it runs into is one sentence that has been in force for 114 years and has been enforced twice. Whether there’s a third time is up to the people who take their seats on January 3.




You're reading it exactly right, Tom, and you're right that the next Congress can tighten it up further. Just eliminate the GAO completely. Overall, the power of the purse is the biggest hammer Congress has. It will require a lot of court decisions to close off all the ways the executive can try to shift money around if Congress starts cutting payrolls or budgets in response to stonewalling. I wrote a post about the need to speed up those kinds of court decisions. https://substack.com/home/post/p-224354349 Thanks.