I wanted crows. I want that on the record, because of what happened, and because people who hear this story assume I’m a bird person, and I’m not. I’m a person who works alone in a back bedroom with a monitor and a window, and sometime in March of 2010 I read that crows recognize human faces, remember them for years, and will bring you things if you feed them. I liked the idea of being recognized by something. I bought a two-pound bag of unsalted peanuts in the shell, poured them into the plastic Phillies cup from the 2008 parade that had been holding pens on my desk, and put a handful on the sill outside the office window every morning at eight, and I waited for the crows.
The crows did not come. The crows had, as far as I could tell, a fine thing going at the Wawa dumpster and no interest in a man’s windowsill. What came, on the fourth day, was a blue jay.
If you’ve never had a jay at arm’s length, they’re bigger than you think and they are rude in a way that feels personal. He landed, looked at the peanuts, looked at me through the glass, screamed once, took the biggest peanut, and left. The next morning he did it again. By the end of the week he was arriving at 7:55 and screaming at the empty sill until I came in with the cup, and I had named him Freddie. You can’t tell a male jay from a female one by looking, so I picked a name that would work either way. I say he. I have no idea. On warm days I’d have the window up with just the screen in, and the scream came through the screen about three times louder than it came through the glass, which Freddie seemed to know. He had a little white fleck on the left side of his crest, like someone had flicked paint at him, which is how I knew it was always the same bird. He’d tap the glass twice with his beak when the sill was empty. Two taps, then the scream. It was a system.
The gifts started in June. I came in one morning and there was a small orange rock on the sill, dead center, where I put the peanuts. I assumed it had fallen from somewhere. The next day it was a blue rock. Then a bit of green sea glass, and we are an hour from any sea. Then a paperclip. Then a marble, a cat’s-eye, in good condition.
I looked it up. Jays do this. Crows do it famously, but jays are corvids too, and there are a few hundred forum posts from people with jays who leave them bottle caps and buttons. One woman in Ohio had a jar of them. So I got a jar. I wrote the date on a strip of masking tape and stuck it on each one, because that’s the kind of person I am, and I kept working, and Freddie kept bringing me rocks three or four times a week, and I thought, this is a nice thing that happened to me. I told my sister. She said, “That’s a nice thing that happened to you.”
Then the quarter.
It was a Tuesday. I remember because I’d been on a call that ran long and when I came back to the window Freddie was already sitting there, next to the coin, looking at me like I was late. I slid the window up and picked it up and it was a quarter. One of the new ones with a national park on the back, the kind that had only started turning up in change that spring, a little worn. I was about to drop it in the jar when I saw the date, and the date was five years from now.
I want to describe what that felt like, and the closest I can get is this: it felt like a typo. A miracle would have felt like something. This felt like a typo. I turned it over, and over, and held it under the desk lamp the way a cashier holds up a fifty. The mint mark was a P. The park was one I’d never heard of. The edge was reeded. It was a quarter.
I said, out loud, to a bird, “Freddie, what the hell.”
And here’s the part I didn’t understand until later. I gave him three peanuts. A gift had always been worth one, and that morning I gave him three, because I was standing there with a coin from the future and the bird was right there and it seemed like the thing to do, and Freddie took all three, one at a time, flying off and coming back, and the last time he came back he looked at me for a while before he left.
The next gift was a piece of foil.
That’s what I called it, because it was the size of a stick of gum and it was silver and it was light. But you couldn’t tear it. You couldn’t crumple it. I folded it and it unfolded. I got a pair of kitchen shears on it and the shears slid off like I was trying to cut water. There was a faint pattern on one side, a grid, too fine to see without my readers. I put it in the jar and then I took it out of the jar and put it in my desk drawer, where I keep the passport.
Four peanuts.
Then a bottle cap, for a soda I had never heard of, in a color I’m going to call purple because there isn’t a word for it. Then a guitar pick with one of those square barcodes on it, the kind that had just started showing up on bus shelters, and my phone had no app that could make sense of it. Then a plastic figure, an inch tall, a sort of armored raccoon, with a studio logo on the base and a copyright line that said 2014. I sat up until eleven that night searching the name on the base and finding nothing and feeling, I’m not proud of this, like a man checking a lottery ticket.
Five peanuts. Then six.
It was my sister who said it, when I finally told her the whole thing. She listened to all of it, and she said, “So he’s figured out what gets the big payout.”
I said that wasn’t how birds worked.
She said, “That’s exactly how birds work. That’s how everything works. You’re training each other.”
I went back to the jar and laid it all out on the desk in order by the masking tape, and she was right. Rock, rock, glass, clip, marble, and then the quarter, and the quarter is where I started reacting, and everything after the quarter was stranger than the thing before it. Freddie brought me the future because the future got six peanuts and a rock got one, and he is a jay, and jays keep books.
Which meant he had somewhere to get it.
I have a trail cam from a period when I thought I’d seen a fox. I put it on the fence, facing the sill. Then I put a second one on the garage, facing the yard, because the first one only showed me Freddie leaving and didn’t show me where. Then I made a spreadsheet, and I’m not going to apologize for the spreadsheet, because it worked. Every visit got a row: date, time, gift if any, number of peanuts, departure heading. I started marking the peanuts too, a little F and the date in Sharpie on each shell, so I could tell on the camera which ones he ate and which he carried off. Forty-one rows in, he’d left northeast thirty-eight times.
Northeast of my house is the end of the street, then a strip of woods that the township calls a greenway and that is in fact a drainage easement, then the back of the Wawa, then Route 70. I walked it on a Saturday in September with a coffee, feeling like an idiot, and it took me eleven minutes to find it, because I was looking for something strange and it wasn’t.
It’s a ditch. A concrete channel about four feet wide behind the Wawa lot, where the parking lot runoff goes, with a grate at one end and a culvert at the other going under the road. There’s a scatter of trash in it the way there’s trash in every ditch in New Jersey. I stood on the edge and looked down and saw a receipt, and I almost didn’t climb down for it, and then I did.
The receipt was from the Wawa. Coffee, a pretzel, a bag of in-shell peanuts. The date was three years out.
I stood in the ditch for a long time. I’d like to say I felt awe. What I felt, first, was that somebody three years from now was still not using the recycling bin.
Then I started picking things up. A straw wrapper. A bread tag. Three bottle caps, two of them normal and one of them the purple. A lost-dog flyer, sodden, half-readable, with a phone number and a photo of a dog named Biscuit, and I knew Biscuit, Biscuit was the puppy the Carrolls two doors down had brought home in August, except in the photo he was full grown and wearing a collar I’d never seen. A twist of the foil, two inches of it, caught on the grate.
Nothing arrived while I watched. Nothing glowed. It was a ditch that drained the wrong way in time, by a little, and only trash came through, because trash is what goes into ditches, and the only creature in the county who’d ever noticed was the one creature whose entire profession is looking for shiny trash in ditches.
Nobody chose him and nobody chose me. He was a jay with a good spot and I was the man with the peanuts.
I took the receipt home and put it in the passport drawer and I did not tell my sister about this part, because there’s a difference between a bird bringing you a coin and you standing in a ditch behind a convenience store holding a receipt for peanuts you haven’t bought.
I thought I knew what it was. Then Mr. Albano told me about the quarter.
Mr. Albano is the old man at the end of the street who has lived there since the houses were built and who will tell you about any of them if you stand still. I asked him, carefully, whether anyone had ever found anything odd in the greenway, and he said oh sure, the ditch, and told me about a kid named Danny Ruiz who in 1994 came home from the ditch with a quarter dated 2005 and got grounded for a week for lying, and then grounded for another week for not backing down, and the Ruizes moved to Delaware in 1998 and the quarter went with them, as far as anyone knew.
I went home and sat at the desk and did the thing I do for a living, which is look at a dataset and ask what it’s telling me that I didn’t ask. Danny Ruiz found a quarter that was eleven years out. I was finding things three to five years out. So the ditch had moods. But the point, the thing that made me get up and walk around the kitchen, was this: Danny’s quarter was from the future in 1994, and 2005 was my past, and I had been dropping 2005 quarters in parking meters and vending machines and the gap between the couch cushions for five years, and a 2005 quarter is nothing, there are a billion of them, except that one of them went somewhere.
The ditch ran both ways.
I stopped throwing away foil. I stopped throwing away anything shiny. It took me two days to admit why, and when I did, I did it properly. I took the piece of foil that wouldn’t tear, and a roofing nail, and I scratched a message into it, which took an hour, because it won’t take a scratch easily either. I kept it short. I wrote the date, and my street, and the words FREDDIE SAYS HELLO, because I couldn’t think what else to say to whoever was on the other end of a drainage ditch, and I walked it to the Wawa at dusk and set it on the grate, weighted with a rock, and walked home.
It was gone in the morning. The rock was there, so it hadn’t washed down. It was just gone.
I waited. A week went by, and then on a Thursday Freddie came to the sill, tapped twice, and set down a peanut.
It wasn’t one of mine. Mine come from the big bag at the hardware store and have a certain look. This was longer, a two-chamber shell, with a reddish skin showing through a crack, the kind that comes in the fancy bag. It was unopened. He set it down and stepped back from it and waited, the way he waited when he’d brought me the quarter, for the reaction.
Somebody got the note. Somebody, somewhen, on the far side of a ditch behind a Wawa, read FREDDIE SAYS HELLO and understood that the only thing that reliably crosses is what a jay will carry, and put a peanut on the grate. It is the best piece of mail I have ever received, and I don’t know who sent it, and I gave Freddie the whole cup.
The second jay came in October.
I heard it before I saw it, because it was a fight. Two jays screaming on the sill, a flurry of blue and that hard clacking they do, and Freddie, my Freddie with the paint fleck, getting pushed off his own window by a bird that looked like him and wasn’t. A ragged bird, missing a tail feather, so that it flew a little crooked when it came back around. Sure of itself in a way Freddie wasn’t yet. It landed on the sill, looked at me, and tapped the glass twice.
I took Freddie’s side. I banged on the window and the big one left and Freddie came back and ate like it was a point of principle. I felt good about that for about a day.
The big one came back the next morning, alone, before Freddie, and tapped twice, and I stood there with the cup and didn’t open the window, and it tapped twice again, and then it turned its head so the left side of its crest was toward me, and there was the fleck.
Birds don’t share marks. I know that now, I looked. A crest fleck is damage or a pigment quirk, it’s one bird’s. I stood there and looked at the fleck and looked at the ragged tail and looked at the thing I had been not-looking at since the fight, which was the band on its right leg. Aluminum, nine digits. It took me three mornings and my readers to get all nine, because the number wraps around the leg and the bird only ever showed me one side at a time.
There’s a federal website where you report bands. On the third morning I typed the number in. The site told me the prefix belonged to a series that hadn’t been issued yet, and asked me to check the number and try again.
I did not try again. I slid the window up and put out a peanut and the big one took it and went northeast, a little crooked, and I sat down at my desk and didn’t do any work.
Here’s what I know.
Jays live seven or eight years in the wild, longer if somebody’s feeding them. The ditch moves things. I had thought it moved trash because trash is what goes in ditches, but a jay goes in ditches. A jay goes in that one most mornings. And a jay that goes through comes back with what it finds there, and takes it to the place it has always taken shiny things, which is a sill on the back of a house where a man will give it peanuts in proportion to his surprise.
I went back to the ditch that afternoon. I climbed down and looked, and in the leaves at the dry end, where things pile up, there were peanut shells, dozens of them. Some were the long reddish kind. Most of them were mine, the plain kind from the hardware store, and I knew they were mine because they had my F on them, in my Sharpie, in my handwriting. Some of the dates were from August and September.
Some of the dates I hadn’t written yet.
I sat on the concrete edge with my feet in the leaves and laughed, because it was funny, and then I stopped, because it wasn’t only funny. I had thought I was the man who got gifts from a bird. I’d told my sister so. I’d put them in a jar. And what the shells said, laid out in the leaves like the jar laid out on my desk, was that I’d been watching a jay cache, the way jays cache, and had mistaken myself for the destination. A jay will dig a peanut back up and hide it again if it thinks anybody saw where it went. This one had found a hiding place nobody could watch, because half of it hadn’t happened yet. Peanuts I’d handed over in August had gone through, and peanuts I hadn’t handed over yet had come back, and somewhere in all that traffic it had been worked out that the man at the window was the bank. You bring him something shiny, he pays out. You carry the payout through the ditch and hide it where nobody’s looking. You come back for it later, when your tail’s a mess.
I was the bank. I’d been the point of nothing, for a bird, for seven months, and I had never been happier in my life.
I put out two piles now. Freddie gets the left one. He takes his and goes northeast, every time, and I don’t follow anymore. The big one gets the right pile, and he’s slower about it. He eats some on the sill, which Freddie never does. He sits. There are mornings he’s there before I am, looking in at the empty chair.
Last week, before he left, he set something down. I’d given him nothing extra, no reaction, no bonus, there was nothing in it for him. It was a small orange rock. The first kind. The kind from June, before any of us knew what the window was for.
I put it in the jar.
I’ve been reading about what it takes to get licensed to band birds. It’s a long process, a couple of years of apprenticeship, and the applications are mostly for people with a research purpose, and I closed the tab. Then I opened it again. I’ve got the number written down. I figure somebody has to put it on him, and I know where he’ll be, and I know what gets him to hold still.




A delightful tale, if Freddie likes gold, suggest good shiny-pickings in both Washington DC (a Pennsylvania Avenue address) and West Palm Beach, if only Freddie could entice the occupant to the culvert ...